Contesting a Trust vs. Contesting a Will

When it comes to estate planning, trusts and wills are two of the most common tools people use to distribute their assets. While these documents serve similar purposes, contesting a trust and contesting a will involve different processes, timelines, and considerations. Understanding these differences can help you navigate what happens if a loved one’s estate plan doesn’t seem right. Let’s dive in.

Understanding the Basics of Trusts and Wills

• Wills: A will is a legal document that outlines how someone wants to distribute their assets. It often names an executor to oversee the process and may address guardianship for minors.
• Trusts: A trust, particularly a living revocable trust, is a legal arrangement where a trustee holds and manages assets on behalf of beneficiaries. Trusts can take effect during a person’s lifetime and often bypass probate, making them a popular choice.

Although both tools outline how to handle assets, the ways they are contested and the grounds for doing so differ significantly.

What Does It Mean to Contest a Trust?

Contesting a trust means challenging the validity of the trust or its amendments. Here are some key points to consider. Grounds for contesting a trust:

• Lack of capacity: The grantor (person who created the trust) must have been mentally capable of understanding the trust when they signed it.
• Undue influence: Someone may have manipulated or pressured the grantor into creating or altering the trust.
• Fraud or forgery: The trust could be contested if it was created under false pretenses or if the grantor’s signature was forged.
• Improper execution: Trusts must meet certain legal requirements to be valid, such as being signed and notarized.
• Process for Contesting a Trust: Trust contests usually occur in probate or civil court, depending on state laws. The process begins by filing a petition to challenge the trust, providing evidence for the claim, and often includes depositions or expert testimonies.
• Timeline for Contesting a Trust: The deadlines, or statutes of limitations, for contesting a trust vary by state. In many cases, the clock starts ticking as soon as distribution begins or beneficiaries receive notice.

What Does It Mean to Contest a Will?

Contesting a will involves disputing its validity, often during the probate process. Here’s what you need to know. Grounds for contesting a will:

• Lack of capacity: Like a trust, the person creating the will (the testator) must have had the mental ability to understand their decisions.
• Undue influence: A will may be invalid if someone coerced or pressured the testator.
• Fraud or forgery: Contesting based on fraud or forgery involves proving the testator’s intentions were misrepresented or their signature was falsified.
• Improper execution: Wills must meet legal standards, such as being signed by the testator and witnessed by others.
• Process: The probate court handles will contests. The process starts with filing a petition during the probate proceedings and presenting evidence to support the claim.
• Timeline: Deadlines for contesting a will are often shorter than those for trusts. The timeframe varies by state but generally begins when the will enters probate or when heirs receive notice.

Key Differences

While the grounds for contesting a trust or a will overlap, several differences set them apart.

Probate Requirements:

• Wills go through probate, providing a structured timeline for contests.
• Trusts generally avoid probate, but contests may still occur in court.

Privacy:

• Wills become part of public records during probate.
• Trusts are private documents, so challenges might reveal less about the estate.

Timeline:

• The window for challenging a will is often shorter.
• Trust contests may have longer or more flexible deadlines, depending on state laws.

Complexity:

• Trust contests often involve detailed financial and management records, adding complexity.
• Will contests focus primarily on the document itself and the testator’s intentions.

In Sum, Contesting a Trust Is Harder

Contesting a trust or a will can be a challenging process emotionally, legally, and financially for all involved. Whether someone is questioning the validity of a loved one’s trust or their will, it’s essential to understand the unique processes involved. (And what makes a trust legally binding.) Because each case is unique. Generally speaking, however, contesting a trust is harder than contesting a will.